|
The Central Issue Price (CIP)
for wheat for the above poverty line (APL) families, which was Rs 450
per quintal in January 1999, had been increased in two steps to Rs 682
per quintal on April 1, 1999. The measures announced in Budget 2000-2001,
along with the subsequent increase in the MSP for wheat, took this up
further to Rs 900 per quintal on April 1, 2000. There was thus a doubling
of the APL wheat price over a fifteen month period. The 52 per cent
hike in PDS prices last year had already caused PDS wheat offtake to
decline from almost 8 million tonnes in 1998-99 to less than 5 million
tonnes during 1999-2000. With the further 32 per cent hike with effect
from April 1, 2000, PDS wheat offtake during April-June 2000 has predictably
plummeted again, to less than 7 lakh tonnes from over 12 lakh tonnes
in the corresponding period last year, despite a doubling of PDS allocation
at half APL prices for the below poverty line population ( chart 7).
Chart 7 >>
Consequently, wheat stocks with
the government, which had reached 13 million tonnes on April 1, 2000
from less than 10 million tonnes on April 1, 1999, are now over 27 million
tonnes. Given the current trend in offtake, wheat stocks at the beginning
of the next marketing season, on April 1, 2001, are likely to be at
least 20 million tonnes, or fully five times the required norm of 4
million tonnes on that day.
The situation in the case of
rice is only slightly better. The PDS issue price for Grade A rice for
above poverty line families had been increased from Rs 700 per quintal
to Rs 905 per quintal in February 1999, and this was increased further
to Rs 1180 per quintal on April 1, 2000. Despite the price rise last
year, PDS offtake during 1999-2000, at 10.9 million tonnes, was almost
unchanged from the offtake of 10.7 million tonnes during 1998-99. This
was because the 29 per cent increase in the rice issue price was almost
half that in the case of wheat, and there was in fact no increase in
prices for consumers in many rice consuming states which chose to absorb
the higher central issue price through enhanced subsidies of their own.
However, rice stocks, which
were slightly less than the required norm of 11.8 million tonnes on
April 1, 1999, increased to 14.9 million tonnes on April 1, 2000 because
procurement of rice this year has also been a record at more than 16
million tonnes. This was partly the result of a better output and because
low world prices had reduced the demand from exporters, but, as in the
case of wheat, the main reason was that the MSP for paddy was fixed
11 per cent above that recommended by the Commission on Agricultural
Costs and Prices. Moreover, this year's hike of 30 per cent in the issue
price of rice has already caused PDS offtake to decline by more than
30 per cent to 1.8 million tonnes during April-June 2000 from 2.6 million
tonnes in the corresponding period of last year, despite the doubled
allowance for below poverty line households. Rice stocks on October
1, 2000, when the next procurement season starts, are therefore expected
to be at least 11.5 million tonnes, well over the required norm of 6.5
million tonnes on that date.
An obvious consequence of such
high stocks is the risk that grains may rot, or be devoured by pests,
simply because of a shortage in storage capacity. The total storage
capacity (including cover and plinth storage which should ideally be
used only temporarily) available at present with the Food Corporation
of India, the Central Warehousing Corporation, and the various State
Warehousing Corporations put together, add up to about 46 million tonnes.
As against this, the publicly held stocks of wheat and rice are presently
in excess of 41 million tonnes, so that the utilisation of available
public sector storage capacity is already around 90 per cent at the
national level. In Punjab and Haryana, stocks already exceed storage
capacity and have to be stored in the open, awaiting transportation
to other locations.
On top of this, paddy procurement
is due to begin in October and, if last year is any indication, about
9 million tonnes of paddy are likely to be procured during the first
six weeks in Punjab and Haryana alone. This influx, given that stocks
on October 1, 2000 may be close to 38 million tonnes, means that all
storage capacity could be exhausted before November-end when stocks
peak before their normal seasonal decline to April. But even if the
situation is managed in October-November, through temporary construction
and recourse to hire of private storage, the problem would recur in
an even more acute form from April 2001 onwards, when wheat procurement
is due to begin. The exact quantum of the problem then will depend on
the size of rice procurement during October-March of the coming season.
Even if rice procurement falls
from over 14 million tonnes last year to 12 million tonnes, the total
stocks at the beginning of the next wheat procurement season are likely
to be over 40 million tonnes at current levels of offtake. Since the
available storage capacity would then permit only a maximum wheat procurement
of around 8 million tonnes, the stark choices at present are limited
to either immediate steps to increase offtake or a crash programme for
godown construction and, failing both these, to a decision to contain
next year's wheat procurement to less than half of this year's actual. |