| Apr
15th 2008,
C.P. Chandrasekhar |
|
Globally,
evidence has been growing that markets are just not
working, precipitating crises that requires bringing
the state back in. The high oil prices, financial crisis
putting government regulation back in vogue and the
crisis in global food markets show that markets cannot
deliver without regulation. But there have been many
areas where apparently successful outcomes of free market
have turned out to be more of a problem that an economic
gain, the foreign reserves issue being a case in point. |
|
| Caste
and Discrimination in Higher Education: Evidence from
the National Sample Surveys |
| Apr
8 th 2008, Jayati Ghosh |
|
|
The
issue of reservations in higher education in India has
been a volatile issue which also has direct implications
not only for public policy but also for the administration
and functioning of academic institutions, not to mention
the fate of a large number of students. This note is
an attempt to add to the currently meagre empirical
literature by analysing the available evidence on the
actual extent of marginalisation and discrimination
apparently faced by different categories in the population,
based on the results of the most recent large National
Sample Survey |
|
| The
New Enclosure Movement |
| Mar
15th 2008,
Jayati
Ghosh |
|
|
A
large part of the rural area around Delhi and other
big cities has been converted from farmland into more
pieces of attractive real estate in a portfolio of land
holding. In the process, the attributes of the villages
of these formerly completely rural areas are changing
fast, not only in terms of ownership and cultivation
patterns, but also in terms of the material means of
support of the local population and their lifestyles.
This also implies significant changes in the nature
and options for employment for the local population.
|
|
| Addressing
Social Concerns |
| Mar
10th 2008,
Jayati
Ghosh |
|
|
The
main issues in this year's economic strategy of the
government, especially the intentions as signalled in
this year's Budget proposals remain the same as that
of 2004. These are employment, the agrarian crisis,
nutrition and food security, education, health and social
security. In each of these areas, the UPA government
promised much. However, the delivery has not only been
far below the promises, but in some cases even worse
than the previous government. |
|
| Farmers'
Suicides in India: Magnitudes, Trends and Spatial Patterns |
| Mar
3rd 2008, K. Nagraj |
|
|
Given
the very large number of suicides by farmers in various
parts of India over the last decade, there is a need
to probe the issue by utilizing a data source which
would provide a comprehensive, nation-wide picture.
This paper is a modest attempt to fill that gap. Its
basic objective is to put together, and carry out a
preliminary analysis on, the secondary data that are
available on farmers' suicides in the country. The paper
studies, first, the magnitude and trends in farmers'
suicides in India over 1997-2006; and second, the regional
patterns, if any, in the incidence and trends in these
suicides. |
|
| The
Farce of "School Choice" |
| Jan
28th 2008, Jayati Ghosh |
| In
India, apart from the factors of poverty, gender and
other inequalities in basic infrastructure, a wide range
of various forms of social discrimination operate to
exclude children from school education and this is even
more pronounced under the private schools. The proposed
voucher system will further strengthen this discrimination
by weakening the public school system. |
|
| Difficulty
of Growing Tails Again |
| Jan
25th 2008, Prabir Purkayastha |
| There
has been a recent parting of the ways between the Left
parties, particularly the CPI(M) and various sections,
which had earlier appeared to be a part of a larger
coalition of forces against imperialist globalisation.
Obviously, Nandigram and Singur are symptomatic of a
much larger difference that existed and which has now
surfaced. This current divergence reflects several issues;
the role of development, the role of the state and the
issue of imperialism. |
|
| The
CPI(M) and the Building of Capitalism |
| Jan
17 th 2008, Prabhat Patnaik |
| This article
argues that the reaction of certain sections of the
media and the younger generation to certain statements
made in the West Bengal CPI(M) political circles which
was read as the CPI(M) having abandoned socialism is
misplaced on three counts. Their arguments do not distinguish
between socialist and people's democratic revolutions;
between working within a system and working not to transcend
the system; and between the Party and Party-led governments.
All of this point towards the complexities of the Indian
revolution and require an in depth understanding of
the political situation. |
|
| The
Left and its "Intellectual Detractors" |
| Dec
12th 2007, Prabhat Patnaik |
| The extreme
hostility of the intellectual community to the Left
Front Government on the Nandigram issue indicates that
the explanation lies beyond the ordinary. It indicates
something more serious, namely the process of destruction
of politics that the phenomenon of globalization has
unleashed. The attitude of the intellectuals arrayed
against the organized Left at present shows complete
withdrawal from the realm of political praxis to a realm
of messianic moralism. |
|
| The
Media and the Left in India |
| Dec
5 th 2007, Jayati Ghosh |
| The
past few weeks have witnessed an extraordinary frenzy
of media attacks on the Left and in particular, on the
Left Front government in the state of West Bengal. The
recent media coverage has included gross and even malicious
distortion of facts apart from being completely one-sided.
Simultaneously, false and extremely dangerous analogies
have been made comparing this to the Gujarat genocide
in 2002 whereas no valid comparison can actually be
made. All this goes to show the control of the media
by an international alliance that works clearly in the
interests of imperialism. |
|
| Disquisitions
of The PM |
| Nov
13th 2007, Prabhat Patnaik. |
| The
recent disquisitions of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh,
which in effect blame the electorate for giving a "fractured
mandate", or in other words denying a clear majority
to the Congress Party, transgress the natural boundaries
of a party's confidence in its party programme or the
degree of impatience with the electorate on the part
of a political party when it does not get the electorate's
support.. |
|
| Can
the PM Cope with Democracy |
| Nov
13th 2007, C.P. Chandrasekhar |
| The
PM periodically expresses his resentment over not being
able to go through with some of his most favoured initiatives.
Two areas in which this resentment is particularly clear
are economic policy and India's international relations,
especially its relations with the United States. It
seems he has begun to consider much that independent
India can be proud of and is enshrined in her Constitution
as a problem, an obstacle in the way of progress as
he sees it. |
|
| On
Nandigram |
| Nov
12th 2007, Jayati Ghosh |
| The
current events in Nandigram in West Bengal show how
the local conflict, which continues to lead to tragic
loss of life, is still being portrayed as a struggle
against land acquisition, when that particular victory
was won several months ago and now the events portray
nothing but political manipulation. |
|
|
The Novartis
Case |
| Oct
8th 2007, Jayati Ghosh |
| The
Madras High Court's recent rejection of Novartis' attempt
to patent the leukaemia treatment drug, sold as Glivec
in India, comes as an unexpected and much welcome break
and a precedent in the fight for cheaper lifesaving
drugs. The crucial question of whether this drug is
actually a new invention or simply a minor modification
of an older, off-patent drug, was one which is often
used by multinational pharmaceutical companies as a
method of prolonging monopoly control over products
that would otherwise move off the patent list. |
|
|
Incorporation
and Exclusion by the Indian State |
| Oct
3rd 2007, Jayati Ghosh |
| The
development project is nowhere near completion in India
and a major reason is that a basic feature of the process
of economic development thus far has been exclusion
in various forms. Exploring the reasons why and how
requires looking into the relationship between the state
and economic development and the class character of
the state which has undergone major changes over this
period and assumed much more complex and multidimensional
forms. |
|
| Land
Acquisition, Corporate Capital and Social Justice |
| Oct
3rd 2007, Ratan Khasnabis |
|
|
This
paper discusses how a massive drive for converting agricultural
land to non-agricultural use is taking place in the
Third World in the recent phase of globalisation, driven
chiefly by corporate capital and often by utilizing
the instrument of state power. The first Section of
this paper discusses the background of land transfer
and the corporatisation of land with special reference
to India, followed by a discussion on the nature of
justice that the dispossessed receive when land is transferred
to the corporate. The role of the state as the mitigator
has also been discussed in this paper. |
|
| ''Two
Nations'' |
| Sep
3rd 2007, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
|
Neo-liberalism
has spawned a more plausible division of the country
into two ''nations'', a term that may not stand up to
strict scrutiny under the canons of Marxist theory,
but nonetheless contains a rich description, reminiscent
of Lenin, of the Indian context. One of these two nations,
the ''nation of the rich'', believes that it belongs
to the first world, while the other, ''the nation of
the poor'', remains stuck in the third world, experiencing
agrarian crisis, unemployment, and privations on account
of cuts in government expenditures, that pervade the
entire third world. |
|
|
Murdoch's
Last Laffer |
| Jul
30th 2007, C.P. Chandrasekhar |
| The
offer by Rupert Murdoch to buy up Dow Jones, which owns
the Wall Street Journal shows that the Journal is now
haunted by its own promotion of changes in American
capitalism that have paved the way for the domination
of merger and acquisitions wave. This has led to conversion
of media empires into typical corporations that are
as much the targets of take-over and seekers of financial
gain as any other. This corporate-led, profit-driven
dynamics underlying this trend, promoted vigorously
by the media itself, has had serious adverse implications
for questions of integrity especially of the financial
media, which the Wall Street Journal projects itself
as promoters of. |
|
| Ashok
Mitra |
| Mar
26th 2007, Jayati Ghosh |
|
This
review of a book of memoirs by Ashok Mitra points out
that all his endearing and contradictory personal attributes,
combined with his indisputable literary flair and prodigious
memory, are what make the book so absorbing and so much
fun to read. The final sections of the book though do
carry perhaps too much of the perception that everything
- even progressive politics and literature - was better
in the past. |
|
| Singur
and the Political Economy of Structural Change |
| Feb
17th 2007, Mritiunjoy Mohanty |
| The
paper explores the controversy that has surrounded the
West Bengal Government's land acquisition programme
in Singur and situates it within the overall context
of economic growth and transformation. It argues one
of the most adversely affected groups as a result of
the acquisition is relatively large farmers for whom
agriculture is a source of accumulation and not livelihood
and subsistence. This might explain in part why the
resistance has been so strong. The paper argues that
equitable and sustained growth is possible only by reducing
the share of agriculture in the labour force and therefore
that the West Bengal Government's strategy has to focus
on maximising the generation of non-farm rural employment. |
|
| The
State Under Neo-liberalism |
| Oct
31st 2006, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
In
this paper, the author discusses a distinct characteristic
of the State under neo-liberalism; a transformation
in its texture through a change in the nature of bureaucracy,
State personnel and ''organic intellectuals''. However
the social legitimacy of the State, under question as
a fall out of the neo liberal economic policies, and
consequently the stability of the Capitalist order will
depend upon its identity of being a supra-social entity.
The State will also try to regain lost social legitimacy
by manufacturing some perceived enemy, in turn giving
rise to jingoism, terrorism and parochial identities.
|
|
| The
Assault of Vulgar Economy |
| Sep
11th 2006, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
To
remain confined to the ''thingness'' of economic categories
without reference to the social relations of which they
were simultaneously the expression, was ''vulgar economy''
according to Karl Marx. Almost a century and a half
after his painstaking work had unearthed the anatomy
of modern bourgeois society, we are once more in the
danger of being deluged by ''vulgar economy'', manifest
in the contemporary Indian discourse on the farmers'
suicides, GDP growth rate and poverty reduction, etc. |
|
| Repeated
Sins of Commission |
| Jun
30th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
One
of the lesser known large dams in the Narmada valley,
the Maheshwar Project, which is the first privatised
hydel project in India, shows all the signs of another
Enron-type fiasco in the making. But, apart from the
flaws on technical and financial grounds, this time
there is also added devastation produced by large scale
displacement and completely inadequate rehabilitation.
|
|
| Bumps
in the Flat World |
| Jun
21st 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
There
are interesting economic and sociological lessons from
the recent story of the Mittal Group's bid for the French
steel company Arcelor. It shows that pure arms length
transactions driven by open competition and efficiency
and unsullied by social and cultural differences do
not exist, and that global capitalism continues to be
shaped by the latter differences.
|
|
| The
Sardar Sarovar Dam: The Legacy of an Indifferent State |
| Jun
14th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
Work
for raising the height of the Sardar Sarovar Dam continues
apace even despite the Supreme Court's orders. The Indian
state not only cannot ensure for many of its citizens
their right to exist, its market-obsessed economic priorities
seem even to have deprived it of the basic political
sense that a democratic state should at least be seen
to be caring for those at the receiving end.
|
|
| Taxation
and the Budget |
| Mar
7th 2006, C.P. Chandrasekhar and Jayati Ghosh |
|
The
increase in central government tax revenues has been
described as a victory for the Laffer Curve in India.
This article examines the real reasons behind the recent
increase in the tax-GDP ratio, in particular, the change
in income distribution and the higher profitability
of companies. |
|
| Appreciating
Argentina |
| Mar
6th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
From
the wreckage of a complex set of volatile and extreme
political and economic changes over the past half century,
the Peronist government led by Nestor Kirchner has,
through its quietly progressive policies, created the
basis for one of the more successful economies in Latin
America at the moment. |
|
| The
Union Budget 2006-07 |
| Mar
2nd 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
The
Budget reveals not only a complex political balancing
act, but also a basic tension between sticking to a
neo-liberal economic strategy and meeting the economic
expectations of the mass of people, generated by the
government's own promises. |
|
| The
Diffusion of Development |
| Feb
18th 2006, Prabhat Patnaik |
|
In
this article, the author discusses the Baran hypothesis
that there cannot be a spontaneous diffusion of industrial
development from the developed world to the countries
of the third world under capitalism: a hypothesis apparently
contradicted by the current pattern of development visible
at least in Asia. His analysis resolves this contradiction
by using an inherent but less talked about 'contradictions
to capitalism' which is the role of a stable medium
of wealth or in the present context, a leading currency.
He explains why the current pattern of growth and technology
diffusion in the newly industrialising countries cannot
be sustained given the necessary pattern of their interaction
with the leading capitalist country. |
|
| Airport
Modernisation: The Real Issues |
| Feb
8th 2006, Jayati Ghosh |
|
Instead
of recognising the real issues and creating the basis
for a genuine national debate on airport modernisation,
most of the mainstream media covering the recent strike
by airport employees has chosen to obfuscate and suppress
the vital information which matters as much for the
future of the country. |
|
| |
| Oct
31st 2005, Jayati Ghosh |
| Of
all the various arguments that have been advanced regarding
the war on terror, those referring to ''the clash of
civilisations'', which argues that there is an innate
civilisational conflict between the values of ''western
democracy'' and Islam, must be among the most foolish.
Given USA's earlier courtships with most of the current
'terror' elements, this proposition seems ridiculous.
|
|